Troubleshooting Cisco UCS LDAP

If you ever configured LDAP integration on a blade chassis or a storage array, you know that troubleshooting authentication is painful on these things. It will accept all your configuration settings and if you’ve made a mistake somewhere all you get when you try to log in is “Authentication Error” message with no clue of what the actual error is.

Committing configuration changes

There three common places where you can make a mistake when setting up LDAP authentication on UCS. Number one is committing configuration changes to the Fabric Interconnects in UCS Manager.

There are four configuration options which you need to set to enable Active Directory authentication to your domain:

  • LDAP Providers – these are your domain controllers
  • LDAP Provider Groups – are used to group multiple domain controllers of the same domain
  • LDAP Group Maps – where you give permissions to your AD groups and users
  • Authentication Domains – final configuration step where you enable authentication via the domain

Now if you decide to delete a LDAP Provider Group which is configured under an Authentication Domain in attempt to change the settings, this may become an issue.

What is confusing here is UCS Manager will let you delete the LDAP Provider Group, save the changes and LDAP Provider Group will disappear from the list. And you may legitimately conclude that it’s deleted from UCS, but it’s actually not. This is what you’ll see in UCS Manager logs:

[FSM:STAGE:STALE-FAIL]: external aaa server configuration to primary(FSM-STAGE:sam:dme:AaaEpUpdateEp:SetEpLocal)
[FSM:STAGE:REMOTE-ERROR]: Result: resource-unavailable Code: ERR-ep-set-error Message: Re-ordering/Deletion of Providers cannot be applied while ldap is used for yourdomain.com(Domain) authentication(sam:dme:AaaEpUpdateEp:SetEpLocal)

The record will stay on the UCS and you may encounter very confusing issues where you change your LDAP Provider settings but changes are not reflected on UCS. So make sure to delete the object from the higher level entity first.

Distinguished Name typos

There are two ways to group Active Directory entities on a domain controller – Security Groups and Organizational Units. When configuring your AD bind account in LDAP Providers section and setting up permissions in LDAP Group Maps, make sure to not confuse the two. The best advice I can give – always use ADSI Edit tool to find the exact DN. Why? As an example let’s say you want to give permissions to the builtin administrator group and you use the following DN:

CN=Administrators,OU=Builtin,DC=yourdomain,DC=com

This won’t work, because even though Builtin container may look like a OU, it’s actually a CN in AD, as well as Users and Computers containers.

adsi_edit.JPG

ADSI Edit will give you the exact Distinguished Name. Make sure to use it to save yourself the hassle.

Group Authorization settings

Last but not least are the following two LDAP Provider configuration settings:

  • Group Authorization – whether UCS searches within groups when authenticating
  • Group Recursion – whether UCS searches groups recursively

If you add an AD group which the user is a part of in LDAP Group Maps and do not enable Group Authorization, UCS simply won’t search within the group. Enable this option unless you give permissions only on a per user basis.

Second option enables recursive search within AD groups. If you have nested groups in AD (which most people have) enable recursive search or UCS won’t look deeper than 1 level.

If you get really stuck

If you’ve set all the settings up and are certain they the are correct, but authentication still doesn’t work, then there is a relatively easy way to localize the issue.

First step is to check whether UCS can bind to your LDAP Providers and authenticate users. Pick a user (LDAP Group Maps don’t matter at this point), SSH to a Fabric Interconnect and type the following:

ucs # connect nxos
ucs(nxos)# test aaa server ldap yourdc.yourdomain.com john password123

yourdc.yourdomain.com – is the domain controller you’ve configured in LDAP Providers section. If authentication doesn’t work, then the issue is in LDAP Provider settings.

If you can authenticate, then the next step is to make sure that UCS searches through the right AD groups. To check that you will need to enable LDAP authentication logging on a Fabric Interconnect:

ucs # connect nxos
ucs(nxos)# debug ldap aaa-request-lowlevel

Now try to authenticate and look through the list of groups which UCS is searching through. If you can’t see the group which your user is a part of, then you most likely using a wrong DN in LDAP Group Maps.

In my case the settings are configured correctly and I can see that UCS is searching in the Builtin Administrators group:

2015 Dec 1 14:12:19.581737 ldap: value: CN=Enterprise Admins,CN=Users,DC=yourdomain,DC=com
2015 Dec 1 14:12:19.581747 ldap: ldap_add_to_groups: Discarding. group map not configured for CN=Enterprise Admins,CN=Users,DC=yourdomain,DC=com
2015 Dec 1 14:12:19.581756 ldap: value: CN=Administrators,CN=Builtin,DC=yourdomain,DC=com
2015 Dec 1 14:12:19.581767 ldap: ldap_add_to_groups: successfully added group:CN=Administrators,CN=Builtin,DC=yourdomain,DC=com
2015 Dec 1 14:12:19.581777 ldap: value: CN=Exchange Organization Administrators,OU=Microsoft Exchange Security Groups,DC=yourdomain,DC=com

Make sure to disable logging when you’re done:

ucs(nxos)# undebug all

References:

Advertisements

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

2 Responses to “Troubleshooting Cisco UCS LDAP”

  1. Tapan Says:

    I am running into the same issue mention in Committing configuration changes How to resolve this now. Kindly suggest

    FSM:STAGE:STALE-FAIL]: external aaa server configuration to primary(FSM-STAGE:sam:dme:AaaEpUpdateEp:SetEpLocal)
    [FSM:STAGE:REMOTE-ERROR]: Result: resource-unavailable Code: ERR-ep-set-error Message: Re-ordering/Deletion of Providers cannot be applied while ldap is used for yourdomain.com(Domain) authentication(sam:dme:AaaEpUpdateEp:SetEpLocal)

    • niktips Says:

      Try to delete Authentication Domains, Group Maps and Provider Groups and recreate the configuration. I don’t know any other way of fixing this.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: